Best Cast Iron Skillet for Cooking With Tallow

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Cast iron and traditional fats go together: a heavy pan holds heat for searing in tallow, and the pan’s seasoning is itself baked-on fat. This guide merges our two cast iron buying guides into one, with every product link re-checked so the link matches the pan named.

Quick answer: Lodge 12-inch Pre-Seasoned Skillet for most kitchens, Lodge 10.25-inch for small households, and a Lodge enamelled Dutch oven for deep frying.

How we chose

This is a desk-researched comparison, not a lab test. We shortlisted products with a current, verified Amazon listing and compared what can be checked: the ingredient list, what the maker states about sourcing and processing, the package, and how each fat fits the cooking jobs on this site. Sourcing and quality claims below are the manufacturers’ own unless a study is cited. We list no prices because they change daily. For cookware we weighed size, weight and what each pan is for, using Lodge’s published specifications.

The picks

1. Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet, 12-inch — Best all-round

• 12-inch cooking surface; listing includes a silicone handle holder
• Pre-seasoned at the factory (Lodge uses a soy-based oil; see FAQ)

Good for: smash burgers, steaks, roast potatoes, cornbread

Check price on Amazon

3. Lodge Essential Enamel Cast Iron Dutch Oven, 6 quart — Best for frying

• 6-quart enamelled cast iron pot with tall sides
• No seasoning needed; suits braises as well as frying

Good for: fried chicken, fries, pot roast

Check price on Amazon

Add a thermometer

Frying in tallow or lard is easier when you can see the temperature. Two instant-read options we list: ThermoWorks Thermapen ONE and Alpha Grillers Instant Read Thermometer.

Seasoning with tallow

Lodge factory-seasons with a soy-based vegetable oil and suggests vegetable or canola oil for re-seasoning [1]. Any fat that bakes on in thin layers builds seasoning, so seed-oil-free cooks can use tallow or lard instead: wipe on a very thin coat, wipe it back off, and bake upside down. Full method: How to Season Cast Iron With Tallow. Tallow picks: Best Beef Tallow Brands.

More cookware: Dutch oven guide · carbon steel wok guide. Part of the Traditional Fats Guide.

Want the short list? Everything we recommend across the site is on one page: our seed-oil-free pantry and cookware picks.

Best cast-iron skillet for searing in tallow: budget, mid and premium

Sizes and features from each Amazon listing title as of October 12, 2026.

Budget pick

Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet, 12 Inches

Budget pick: heavy enough to stay hot when the meat goes in, for a proper crust on smash burgers.

Check price on Amazon

Mid pick

Stargazer 12-Inch Cast Iron Skillet

Mid pick: made in the USA with a smooth cooking surface, per the listing.

Check price on Amazon

Premium pick

Field Company No.12 Cast Iron Skillet, 13.4 Inch

Premium pick: the listing describes it as lighter and smooth, sized for 6 to 8 servings.

Check price on Amazon

Alternative

de Buyer Mineral B Carbon Steel Fry Pan, 10.25 Inch

The carbon steel alternative: thinner and quicker to heat.

Check price on Amazon

Alternative

All-Clad D3 Stainless Steel 10" Fry Pan with Lid

The stainless alternative to nonstick, for pan sauces like pork chops with cider sauce.

Check price on Amazon

Who it is for

Buy cast iron if you sear meat, fry eggs or bake cornbread often and do not mind the weight. Choose carbon steel if weight bothers you, and clad stainless if you want a pan for acidic sauces. For deep frying, use a deep fryer or an enamelled Dutch oven instead.

Last reviewed: October 12, 2026.

Frequently asked questions

What size cast iron skillet should I buy first?

A 10.25-inch skillet suits one or two people; a 12-inch skillet fits four chicken thighs or two steaks. If you only buy one and cook for a family, go 12-inch.

Is new cast iron seasoned with seed oil?

Lodge says it factory-seasons its cast iron with a soy-based vegetable oil. If you want to avoid that, you can build your own layers of seasoning over it with tallow or lard; see our guide to seasoning cast iron with tallow.

Can I deep-fry in cast iron?

USDA FSIS advises against cast iron for deep frying because it breaks down oil faster. Use an enamelled Dutch oven or a deep fryer, and keep cast iron for searing and shallow frying.

Enamelled or bare cast iron?

Bare cast iron builds seasoning and suits searing and frying. Enamelled cast iron needs no seasoning and suits acidic braises, so follow the maker’s heat guidance.

Cast iron or carbon steel?

Both sear well in tallow. Carbon steel is lighter and thinner, so it heats faster; cast iron is heavier and holds heat longer once hot.

Is stainless steel a good non-toxic alternative to nonstick?

Yes, for cooks avoiding nonstick coatings. Clad stainless such as All-Clad D3 browns well and can go from hob to oven; use enough fat and let the pan heat first.

Sources

1. Lodge Cast Iron: What oils should you use for cast iron cooking and seasoning? — Lodge factory-seasons with a soy-based vegetable oil

Browse Savannah's Amazon Storefront →

New to cooking with tallow? Our guide explains what tallow is and how to render it.