The Dutch oven is the most important piece of cookware for anyone cooking in ancestral fats. Every long-cooked dish on this site — Moroccan lamb tagine, short ribs, pulled pork, bone broth, biryani, doro wat, osso buco — requires a heavy, tightly lidded pot that holds a steady low temperature for hours without scorching. This is the Dutch oven's entire purpose. The question is not whether to buy one but which one.
The Three Choices
There are three meaningful choices at different price points: Lodge enamelled cast iron ($90), Emile Henry tagine ($180, for Moroccan cooking specifically), and Le Creuset enamelled cast iron ($420). Each is correct for a different buyer. Here is how to choose.
What to Cook in a Dutch Oven
- Bone broth — 24 hours on lowest heat, or 3 hours in an Instant Pot
- Moroccan lamb tagine — 3 hours covered at 160°C
- Short ribs braised in butter — 3.5 hours covered
- Beef stew in tallow — 2 hours
- Osso buco in butter — 2.5 hours
- Doro wat — 2 hours
- Kalua pig — 8 hours at 160°C
- Pulled pork in lard — 6-7 hours
- Biryani dum pukht — sealed and slow-cooked 25 minutes
Why Not a Slow Cooker?
A slow cooker is an acceptable substitute for the oven braising stage of most recipes but cannot produce the initial sear that gives braised dishes their colour and depth. The Dutch oven's advantage is that the same vessel browns the meat on the hob, then transitions directly to the oven for the long cook. One pot, maximum flavour. A slow cooker requires a separate searing step or skips it entirely — both produce inferior results.
What size Dutch oven do I need?
5-6 litres handles most recipes for 4 people. If you regularly cook for 6+ or make large batches of bone broth, buy 7-8 litres.
Enamelled or plain cast iron?
Enamelled for tomato-based braises, wine braises, and anything acidic. Plain cast iron for pure fat-based braises and bone broth. If buying one, enamelled is more versatile.
Is Le Creuset worth the money?
For most people, Lodge is 85% of the performance at 20% of the price. Le Creuset is worth it if you cook braises multiple times per week and want the marginal improvements in heat distribution and lid seal.
Follow Savannah: @theefoodiekitchen · Facebook · All Links
African, Hawaiian, Indian, Mediterranean, Asian, Exotic, Chicken, Rice, Cookies, Coffee, Spices, Plants, World Cuisine, 30-Minute Dinners and more.
View All 23 Books on Amazon →